Return of Capital (or RoC) distributions are sometimes sold as tax free distributions. This is true, but not without some hidden knowledge. True, you do get the distribution tax free; but false, you WILL have to pay taxes on your investment. RoC works like the following:
Invest $1000 in Stock A
We’ll assume for simplicity, that the stock’s share price does not increase or decrease in value until the distribution date
Stock A pays a distribution of 5% ($50), of which 100% is RoC.
That $50 is totally tax free! Why? well, because your cost base of your investment is now only $950. That’s not to say you only have $950 invested, your book value is still $1000, but $50 of your original investment is returned to you as a distribution. So what does this really mean? well, even though you have not made any money on your investment (share price remained the same), if you sold your investment at this share price, you would trigger capital gains since your investment “made” $50 (since your ACB is only $950). Extrapolate this into the future and you will see that you eventually end up with an ACB of $0, which means that you will eventually have to pay capital gains taxes on 100% of your book value, that is you pay your book value at your marginal rate, YIKES!!!.
Ok, so you are probably wondering why in the world would you want something that returns RoC distributions? well, in the proper investment vehicle, you will not have to deal with the capital gains, such as a TFSA or an RSP account. I think RoC’s are useful for corporations, but i really can’t tell you why. All you need to remember is that they can be dangerous because of their ACB adjusting properties.
To make things worse, if you are using borrowed money to invest (making your loan interest payments tax deductible), then any RoC distributions can wreak havoc on your loan’s tax deductibility. This is because the amount of the RoC is “no longer invested” so you could not claim that your full loan amount is being invested to generate income. There is a fix for this, and here it is. You can either calculate the portion of your distribution that is RoC and simply re-invest that portion right away (thus keeping the loan fully invested). Or you can alternatively capitalize your loan’s interest with RoC income, because your loan’s interest is still tax deductible if you use your loan to pay for your loan’s interest (hopefully that makes sense, if it doesn’t then don’t worry, it’s all good).
That last point is especially important for Smith Manoeuvre warriors, since you can take advantage of funds that have RoC in your SM account. I really don’t suggest doing this on purpose unless there is a compelling reason. In my case, the reason being that there are no Canadian dividend ETF’s that are fully tax efficient. Best i could find was XDV and it still has a small RoC portion. The fix isn’t cut and dry, but it is still fairly simple, just a few extra manual transactions. Ideally, however, I would rather avoid RoC’s altogether.
p.s. Thanks to Frugal Trader over at Million Dollar Journey for the insight into capitalizing the LoC interest. I had originally just thought of re-investing, but capitalizing is much smarter since you can just re-borrow it again right away.